Fight Club

The book I’m reading for the literature circle is Fight Club. I was glad that I got to read this book because it was my first choice and I really enjoyed the movie. However, Mrs. Clinch stated that the book is radically different from the movie. Well I read the first 8 chapters, and up to that point, the plot of the book is nearly identical to the plot in the movie. I was up at my friend’s cabin this weekend and was reading the novel when my friend pointed out that the book was almost like a movie screen. And because of the similarity in the book and movie, I assumed that the conclusion of the novel would match that of the movie—tyler durden and the narrator are one person. Under this assumption, I noticed many clues within the text that pointed towards my assumption. For instance, in the first chapter, Tyler and the narrator are always mentioned together in tandem. But, I learned today in class that the ending of the movie is not the same as the ending in the novel. I’m glad I realized this so that I can read without trying to figure contextual clues that pointed to Tyler and the narrator being one person. The novel is definitely raw and gritty. In other words, it’s not meant for the weak of heart. I thought that the narrator’s desire to overturn the norm of society was interesting. The novel is essentially about existential nihilism, which refers to the philosophy that suggests life is without an intrinsic purpose or objective. Because of the narrator’s day-to-day lifestyle, he views it as a static picture without any surprises or excitement. This is where the fight club comes in. Both the narrator and tyler start this club to break out of society. The book mentions self destruction, which is basically fighting. The narrator basically wants to test his limits not only in fighting, but the boundaries of society as well. He is finally fed up with being normal and blending into the background. I found that this idea of reaching bottom before you can be saved is prevalent throughout this novel. Besides fighting, the narrator regularaly attends different support group meetings although he is perfectly healthy. He claims that at these meetings he feel better about himself because he can witness the pains and harshness of life. There, he can see what it means to truly reach bottom and therefore be saved. The book alludes to Jesus Christ and him reaching bottom by being crucified. This idea of reaching bottom is flawed in my opinion. You don’t necessarily have to reach the rock bottom to realize and be thankful for your situation. I also realized that Tyler is the more aggressive and alpha male in the relationship he shares with the narrator. If the novel is not like the movie where they are the same person, I wonder who Tyler Durden really is, is he a real person or just a figment of the narrator’s imagination? Im excited to find out!